365 List by Category

And to make it easier to find something more specific, here is a list sorted by categories. 

Snacks

Beef Jerky*
Caramel: sauce, fruit dip, candies*
Cream Cheese Fruit Dip*
Flavored Sunflower Seeds
Fruit Cups*
Pudding: Vanilla*

Condiments

Apple Butter*
BBQ Sauce
Chocolate Sauce
Dill Pickles*
French Dressing
Fruit Topping: quick & easy*, with pectin
Jam: pectin free raspberry, pectin free blackberry*, pectin free strawberry, strawberry, jalapeno*
Ketchup
Maple Syrup
Mayo
Peanut Butter
Relish*
Ranch*
Salsa*: fresh, canned
Soy Sauce
Thousand Island Dressing*
Teriyaki Sauce
Wine Vinegar

Breakfast

Bagels: plain, cinnamon & sugar, jalapeno
Biscuits*
Cinnamon Rolls*
Granola*
Sausage Gravy*

Milk & Dairy

Butter
Buttermilk*
Half & Half*
Pasteurized Eggs*
Ricotta Cheese*
Shredded Cheese*
Sour Cream
Whipped Topping*
Yogurt

Herbs & Spices

Celery Salt*
Herbs
Italian Seasoning*
Pizza Sauce Mix*
Pumpkin Pie Spice*
Spaghetti Sauce Seasoning Mix*
Steak Seasoning*
Taco Seasoning*

Baking

Baking Powder*
Brown Sugar*
Cake Flour*
Cooking Spray*
Extract: Vanilla*
Evaporated Milk
Marshmallow Fluff*
Pie Crust*
Self-Rising Flour*
Sweetened Condensed Milk

Canned Goods

Applesauce*
Canned Beans*
Chicken Broth
Cream of Something Soup or mix
Pumpkin Puree
Refried Beans*
Tomato Sauce

Produce

Fresh Produce: garden plot
Garden Starters*

Meats & Deli

Coleslaw*

Breads & Bakery

Bagels: plain, cinnamon & sugar, jalapeno
Bakery Cakes: Ella Scharlach Cake, DIY Decorating*
Cinnamon Rolls*
Cookies: refrigerator/freeze cookie rolls, Lofthouse*
Pizza Dough*
Tortilla Shells

Frozen

Rice & Pasta

Mac & Cheese*
Noodles

Health & Beauty

Antacid Relief
Bath Salts*
Bronzer*
Conditioner: Apple Cider Vinegar Rinse
Deodorant
Dry Shampoo*
Eye Make-up Remover
Face Powder*
Face Wash*
Facial Moisturizer*
Hair Detangler*
Hair Putty: Shealoe
Mascara
Moisturizer
Shampoo: No-Poo
Shaving Cream
Sugar Scrub
Toothpaste

Household

All Purpose Cleaner*: Norwex clothes, orange infused vinegar
Ant Bait*
Dishwasher Detergent*
Laundry Soap*
Stain Remover: gel*, spray
Washing Soda
Windex*

Outdoors & Auto

Armorall*
Car Wash*
Garden Fertilizer: compost bin
Garden Pesticide: Weed Killers, spray
Tick Repellent*

* - has been completely replaced with homemade version ... no more store bought

The ones not marked are items I have tried and either due to time, money, or taste I am still working to find a way to replace them that works best for us. My goal is to be able to eventually mark all items with an asterisk! As of 2/1/2016 we have 105 items of our 365 tried.